Etsy vs. Shopify: How to Make The Move | Taylor Anne Creative

Etsy vs. Shopify: When & How to Make the Move from Etsy to Shopify

web design
Branding
follow @taylorannecreative

I’m a teacher-turned-designer with a penchant for pour-over coffee and a moderate obsession with fonts. I live to bring beautiful, strategic brands and websites to life for female business owners doing big things.

Hi, I'm Taylor

When you’re trying to figure out the best place to host your online retail shop, I know it can be a little overwhelming. If you’ve been weighing your options between Etsy vs. Shopify and considering a move, there’s a lot to consider: 

  • Where do you begin? 
  • What are the benefits of making that switch?
  • How do you do it without disrupting your business?
  • When’s the right time? 

Don’t worry, I’ve got the answers to all your questions covered in this blog!

I know the ins and outs of moving from Etsy to Shopify, and I’m here to give you my (honest) opinion on the pros and cons of the two platforms. That way, you’ll feel informed, empowered, and confident enough to make the right choice for your business. Be sure to stick around to the end–I’ll give you some surprising Shopify stats to help you decide based on your own business data.

The Pros and Cons of Selling Products on Etsy vs. Shopify

There’s a reason so many up-and-coming e-commerce businesses get their start by selling products on Etsy. It’s a platform where many shops gain their following and really build their customer base. But there’s also a reason that many business owners eventually move their online shops elsewhere. 

Let’s break down the pros and cons of the platform:

The Pros of Selling Your Products on Etsy

1. It’s Easy to Build a Following

In their own words, Etsy is “the global marketplace for unique and creative goods. It’s home to a universe of special, extraordinary items, from unique handcrafted pieces to vintage treasures.” In 2020, that universe of items saw more than 34.9 million active buyers worldwide. 

Access to that type of audience is a fantastic perk for new businesses that are just starting to make a name for themselves. Thanks to Etsy’s on-site search function as well as its compatibility with search engines, customers can organically find new businesses when they’re on the hunt for products. 

An Etsy search window is shown. Learn about Etsy vs. Shopify from Taylor Anne Creative.

2. Learn About E-commerce at a Low Cost

Starting your shop on Etsy is a great way to market-test and perfect your products and learn the e-commerce-ropes as your business grows. For example, if you’re seeing plenty of traffic to your Etsy store, but few conversions to customers, you know you need to switch something up in your current strategy. It’s better (and less expensive!) to figure this out early on, before investing in professional branding and a Shopify site. 

With Etsy, online businesses can also avoid monthly fees. Etsy sellers instead pay $.20/listing, plus $0.25/sale + 6.5% transaction fees. All in all, it’s a pretty low-risk investment when you’re just getting started and testing the waters.

The Cons of Selling Your Products on Etsy

1. Etsy’s Search Algorithm Changes Often

Remember how I mentioned that Etsy’s search function is excellent for helping customers find your products? Well, Etsy’s search algorithm is also constantly changing. This means that as a business owner, you have to stay on top of its changes and be ready to change your techniques as you go if you want your store to be successful.

At the end of the day, you don’t own your shop’s traffic, and you’re at the mercy of Etsy’s algorithm. Remember how Instagram changed its algorithm, and now we never see static posts? 

When customers search for products like yours, your listings appear next to your biggest competitors. For example, one of my favorite jewelry businesses is on Etsy. I’m a repeat customer, and Etsy knows this. However, Etsy always greets me with a landing page full of similar jewelry to what I’ve purchased in the past.  But, it’s NOT created by the store I love. 

See, the same reason you might love Etsy initially (you get new eyes on your product!) might quickly become the bane of your business if you find yourself losing customers to your competitors.

2. Fees Only Stay Low for So Long

And those Etsy listing fees? They add up quickly! Of course, when you’re just getting started and your sales volume is low, the fees are minimal. But as soon as you start generating business and seeing those sales (hopefully!) go up and up, Etsy’s fees will quickly climb past what you would be paying in Shopify. 

Views of an online shop from a tablet, laptop, and mobile with color swatches. Learn about Etsy vs Shopify from Taylor Anne Creative.

Let’s do some quick Etsy vs. Shopify math:

  • If your average order amount is $40 and you make 10 sales/month, you would pay $42.50 in Etsy fees and $51.60 in Shopify fees on Shopify’s Basic plan. 


But…

  • As soon as you start making just 21 sales/month, Etsy and Shopify fees are equal! 
  • By the time you make 100 sales/month, you would save over $170/month by using Shopify vs. Etsy ($253 vs. $425). That’s because Etsy’s transaction fee is set at 6.5% vs. 0-2% with Shopify. The more orders your store receives, the more you’ll save by using Shopify.

So, What’s an E-commerce Business Owner to Do?

Just like any other big decision for your business, deciding on Etsy vs. Shopify is up to you and where you’re at. Every business is different, and there’s no one right answer. 

One nice thing about moving from Etsy to Shopify is that you don’t have to completely go cold turkey on Etsy as you transition your shop. You can keep your hands in both platforms for a while as you get your bearings if it makes you feel more comfortable. It might be a bit of a headache when tracking inventory, though, so I wouldn’t recommend doing that for too long.

Taylor Anne Creative shares her best tips for transitioning from Etsy to Shopify.

Looking for more Shopify resources? You can find all of our Shopify blog posts here.

Ready to Make Your Move?

If reading this made you think, “Yes, I’m ready for Shopify,” I’m here to help you with the design and setup services you need to make your new site shine. Fill out my contact form to get in touch with me and learn how we can work together.

Client Praise

Kate Regan

"What Taylor created for me absolutely blew me away! Her talent, vision, and support are unmatched. Taylor is THE person to go to for all things branding and web design, especially for women-owned businesses."

Christine Sinak

"Taylor considered EVERYTHING. She has this beautiful capacity to attend to every small detail, and hold those details in relationship to the larger brand identity. Having a logo is not the same as having a brand strategy. I'm not sure everyone gets that. What she has given me is far more comprehensive. I'm so grateful!"

Lindsey Warren

"Taylor truly was the best to work with. Her kindness, patience, and attention to every lovely detail just made the whole website the website of my dreams!"

Nina Gibson

"I wasn't expecting how soulful this whole experience would be. Taylor is authentic, transparent, intuitive & insightful. Her ability to really listen & understand my thoughts about the vision for my new brand & bring those to life was such an exciting & awesome process."

Callan Wall

"Working with Taylor felt like a seamless collaboration. She has an incredible gift of taking her client's vision and creating something cohesive and beautiful."

Rebecca Zeltmann

"When I started working with Taylor, I knew who my niche was, but I didn't know how to put it into a business model. Taylor helped me bring everything together into a defined brand and beautiful, professional product that represented my vision."

Holly Haynes

"Taylor is super organized, very talented, & highly invested in her clients' success. She goes above & beyond to find the best solution for your brand."

Jennifer McGurk

"Working with Taylor has been the best business decision! Her design skills exceeded my expectations. She helped bring my vision to life far better than what I could have imagined in my head."

Taylor Wolfram

"Taylor designed a beautiful sales page for my online course. She was so patient with me & I felt like she really went above & beyond with communication and responding to my requests."

ready to level up?

Building Irresistible Brands for Passionate Women

Let’s craft a magnetic brand and a website that sells for you. Done and done! 

All rights reserved

Copyright 2022 Taylor anne Creative